Absolutely stop all tourists including Americans from visiting. It is unrealistic to 'manage' the pandemic where there is great health infrastructure without losing serious numbers.
Central and South America are in serious trouble and are the reason the global trajectory for numbers dying are going up.
People's lives are more important than profits.
Islands can benefit from the lessons learned by the 'New Zealand approach, and that's not just in the Carribean--Hawaii is a great candidate to have a more agressive appraoch.